"Best handling car" test in Motor Trend | FerrariChat

"Best handling car" test in Motor Trend

Discussion in 'General Automotive Discussion' started by Adrift, Jun 7, 2007.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. Adrift

    Adrift Formula Junior

    Aug 30, 2004
    749
    Dallas area
    #1 Adrift, Jun 7, 2007
    You guys see that? Just picked it up in the airport for on-the-plane reading. The short version is:
    1) GT3
    2) Cayman S
    3) Lotius Exige S
    4) Evo IX MR
    5) Mini Cooper S JCW GP
    6) BMW 335i
    7) Honda S2000 (the only rag top)
    8) Mazdapseed 3
    9) Z06
    10) Honda Civic Si

    The car mix was an attempt to represent all major configurations...front-engined FWD, front-engined RWD, AWD, mid-engined, and rear-engined. Obviously they omitted rear-engined AWD (911C4S or TT), but I am sure another Porsche would have seemed tiresome. :D They gave major credit to the Michelin Cup tires for the GT3's performance, but caveating it with an observation that the tires are hazardously slick in anything but totally dry conditions.

    Very surprising was the Z06's next to last place finish (9th), they cite due to too much power and not enough rear grip.

    PS They said they didn't include the "almost affordable" F430 "because the GT3 outperforms it in all our standard handling tests - for $60,000 less." Ahem.
     
  2. parkerfe

    parkerfe F1 World Champ

    Sep 4, 2001
    12,887
    Cumming, Georgia
    Full Name:
    Franklin E. Parker
    #2 parkerfe, Jun 7, 2007
    The EVO IX does pretty good for a 4 door sedan...I can't wait to get my EVO X early next year!
     
  3. kaisen

    kaisen Karting

    Nov 15, 2005
    223
    Minneapolis
    #3 kaisen, Jun 7, 2007
    Wasn't that last month's issue? Old news. Hashed out on lots of forums.
     
  4. kaisen

    kaisen Karting

    Nov 15, 2005
    223
    Minneapolis
    #4 kaisen, Jun 7, 2007
    P.S.: Put Cup tires on a Cayman S and it might have won.
     
  5. Evan.Fiorentino

    Evan.Fiorentino F1 Rookie

    Aug 23, 2005
    2,854
    South East Florida
    Full Name:
    Evan
    #5 Evan.Fiorentino, Jun 7, 2007
    A GT3 outhandling an Exige????
     
  6. Adrift

    Adrift Formula Junior

    Aug 30, 2004
    749
    Dallas area
    #6 Adrift, Jun 7, 2007
    It was a whole slew of tests, with more measuring equipment than they say they have ever assembled before. It was a summary of like 8 or 9 criteria that yielded a composite result. I think the Exige suffered in a number of categories, including "lots of drama at the limit" (measured as "average slip angle rate" at laguna seca).
     
  7. Evolved

    Evolved F1 Veteran

    Nov 5, 2003
    8,700
    #7 Evolved, Jun 7, 2007
    EVO IX only car on the list with baby seat hooks!
     
  8. Gary(SF)

    Gary(SF) F1 Rookie

    Oct 13, 2003
    3,637
    Los Altos Hills, CA
    Full Name:
    Gary B.
    #8 Gary(SF), Jun 7, 2007
    Having personally driven the first three at track events, I would invert the finishing order. This is Motor Trend after all. And the F430 handling is very comparable to the GT3 and superior in many ways. The big advantage the stock 997 GT3 has over the stock F430 is R compound tires.

    Gary
     
  9. kaisen

    kaisen Karting

    Nov 15, 2005
    223
    Minneapolis
    #9 kaisen, Jun 7, 2007
    Yep. The right R compound tires and a suspension tuned to extract the most from them can be a REAL game changer.
     
  10. Cajun

    Cajun Formula 3

    Mar 20, 2004
    1,618
    Da BY-U
    Full Name:
    MJG
    #10 Cajun, Jun 7, 2007
    Interesting observation...
     
  11. dave_fonz_164

    dave_fonz_164 Formula 3

    Mar 11, 2004
    1,658
    Montreal, Canada
    Full Name:
    Davide Giuseppe F.
    #11 dave_fonz_164, Jun 7, 2007
    Whats so suprising about a GT3 being more effective around the track than a 430, i would hope so if i paid for a so called track-street legal car like the GT3, just notice the difference between a 360 and CS on a track, its pretty impressive to say the least. Now well have to wait and see what the 430CS can do.
     
  12. Adrift

    Adrift Formula Junior

    Aug 30, 2004
    749
    Dallas area
    #12 Adrift, Jun 7, 2007
    The article discusses whether having the Cup tires on the GT3 was valid or not, and concluded that it was since the GT3 can be delivered from the factory that way. Seems a reasonable stance, given that they then warn about wet weather behavior.

    I would also have liked to see what a Cayman would have done with Cup tires.
     
  13. RoWis

    RoWis F1 Rookie

    Apr 19, 2006
    4,845
    Vancouver, B.C.
    #13 RoWis, Jun 7, 2007
    I do believe it, the GT3 is a very good handling car
     
  14. parkerfe

    parkerfe F1 World Champ

    Sep 4, 2001
    12,887
    Cumming, Georgia
    Full Name:
    Franklin E. Parker
    #14 parkerfe, Jun 8, 2007
    The tires on my Bimmer Cupped one time and it made the car handle terrible!
     
  15. kaamacat

    kaamacat Formula 3

    Jun 13, 2004
    1,623
    Cumming GA
    Full Name:
    BobR
    #15 kaamacat, Jun 8, 2007
    Point taken on tires...... but the Lotus comes with R-Compound Yokohamas also I believe.

    Looking more at that same report...... the power came to play a bit there also. (I'd say if you gave the CaymanS some more, it could be in the very top)......... Very neutral car do drive......

    But taking the report for what is its, and that the cars come "that way" from the factory, not a bad review. (because you could obviously what-if-the-car-had....... all day)
     
  16. FerrariF50lover

    FerrariF50lover Formula 3

    Aug 12, 2005
    2,383
    Ohio
    Full Name:
    Nate
    #16 FerrariF50lover, Jun 8, 2007
    The Z06 is the only car over 400hp. Of course it will have traction issues when compared to cars like the Exoige.
     
  17. Adrift

    Adrift Formula Junior

    Aug 30, 2004
    749
    Dallas area
    #17 Adrift, Jun 8, 2007
    Not true. The GT3 has 415HP.
     
  18. switchcars

    switchcars Formula 3

    Jul 28, 2005
    2,216
    Full Name:
    Doug
    #18 switchcars, Jun 8, 2007
    Sweet! I've owned or driven half that list.....now I need to go test-drive the other half to see what I'm missing :)
     
  19. furious_ferrari

    furious_ferrari F1 Rookie

    Nov 25, 2005
    3,160
    Vancouver, Canada
    Full Name:
    Phil
    #19 furious_ferrari, Jun 8, 2007
    Mazdaspeed 3 out handling a Z06? Must of been on some really really tight course. I dont even wanna bother with the article.
     
  20. Adrift

    Adrift Formula Junior

    Aug 30, 2004
    749
    Dallas area
    #20 Adrift, Jun 8, 2007
    The article looks at more than fat tires and stiff suspension. It is a fairly involved evaluation of a number of criteria that result in a final rating. The Z06 suffered a lot due to too much power and not enough rear grip.

    Read it.
     
  21. tervuren

    tervuren Formula 3

    Apr 30, 2006
    2,469
    #21 tervuren, Jun 8, 2007
    So if they had of put a rev limiter on - would they have rated it higher?
     
  22. Limeade

    Limeade Karting

    Mar 20, 2006
    127
    #22 Limeade, Jun 8, 2007
    WOW the 335i? Hmmm, are these supposed to be the best handling cars they've ever tested? The G35S sedan out handles the 335I, and the 350z track edition should be on there too.
     
  23. OC Speed Junkie

    OC Speed Junkie Formula 3

    Aug 6, 2005
    2,473
    Southern California
    Full Name:
    Joseph
    #23 OC Speed Junkie, Jun 8, 2007
    I enjoy motor trend for the pictures. That is all. There comparisons are rubish. I take more weight in Jeremy Clarksons optinion on cars handling. As far as the z06, all I can say is driver without enough talent. Honda Civic si? WTF
     

Share This Page