Considering jumping in to a 458, advice? | FerrariChat

Considering jumping in to a 458, advice?

Discussion in '458 Italia/488/F8' started by Ndlauer1027, Dec 26, 2020.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

  1. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Hi All,

    I am brand new to the site. I’ve read for a few hours and see there is a ton of info. I’d really appreciate any and all advice a first time Ferrari owner should know.

    I’m looking at finding a 458 spider. Budget wise I’d like to be at 200k and preferably less as I feel comfortable in the 165-175k range but for the right car/value 200k is doable. I’m terrified of the maintenance on these, getting taken advantage of and not finding any issues upon an inspection. I’d of course have an inspection done or preferably find a Ferrari certified unit. I’m nervous about the venture because of my lack of knowledge and a potential money pit situation. I don’t want this to scare me off of this new interest by being burned up front of finding a car that ends up killing me maintenance wise.

    I know cars of this type are a bad investment, I realize I’ll be losing money but gaining a whole experience of ownership and I am fine with that.

    A few questions to get started are;
    - If I purchase a lower mileage 458, what would I expect to lose on average in value every 12 months?
    -Annual maintenance seems to be a fluctuate based on opinion. In terms of models, would a 458 be a good choice for keeping those costs down?
    -Any year of 458 to stay away from?
    -Asking prices seem to vary greatly on these for similar miles and year, how do I know if something is a fair deal? I understand some of the fluctuations are due to options and original msrp.

    I live in IL and was considering a Montana Llc to title the car for the sales tax advantage. I’ve never done this but stumbled across it recently. I need to purchase some new Escalades as well and may put those there as well. The wonderful state of IL has now capped our trade in value at 10k for sales tax deduction. Between a few Escalades at 110k each and possibly a 458, this could be an absolute huge tax savings. based on our tax rate I’d be looking at saving like 35k on the three vehicles. A little off topic I know but hoping some other forum members have been able to take advantage of this as well.
     
    Greg911 and Thecadster like this.
  2. Extreme1

    Extreme1 Formula 3

    Jun 27, 2017
    1,229
    Santa Clarita, CA
    Look on You Tube and search for Normal Car Guy. He used to have a 430 and now he has a 458. I spent hours watching his videos over and over and learned how to do the maintenance on my 430. It would be a way to avoid the high costs of maintenance, if you are a little bit mechanically inclined. Also look for an independent shop that will be less expensive than a dealer.

    If you’ve done oil changes on your other cars, you can do them on a 458. There’s also threads in the 458 section that will help you with the maintenance. Remember it’s just a car, don’t get freaked out because it has the Ferrari name.


    Sent from my iPad using FerrariChat.com mobile app
     
    ScuderiaScorpion and VAF84 like this.
  3. Mikael-F360

    Mikael-F360 Formula Junior

    Apr 3, 2017
    751
    Finland
    Full Name:
    Mikael E.
    Losing money when the value drops yearly? Not a problem with a 458. Keep it well and it will appreciate.

    Join Ferrari Club of America. You will find enthusiasts there who will give you good advice. Same here at FChat.
     
  4. FFan5

    FFan5 Formula Junior

    Jul 7, 2018
    533
    Hahahahaha. How many have you purchased so far?

    Sent from my Pixel 4 XL using FerrariChat.com mobile app
     
  5. Mikael-F360

    Mikael-F360 Formula Junior

    Apr 3, 2017
    751
    Finland
    Full Name:
    Mikael E.
    One. And it had appreciated 10kEur in last five years.

    So wake up and smell the coffee boy ;)
     
  6. triathgeek

    triathgeek Karting
    Silver Subscribed

    Jul 25, 2010
    116
    Santa Clarita, CA
    2010 458:
    My 2 cents/experience.
    Purchased 6 years ago with 5500 miles; now has 22,000 miles. Avg cost of maint. over the 6 years including tires has been $3600/yr though a good independent specialist. Did 5 PPI's via the independent specialist (not dealer) before selecting this one; best money I ever spent. Depreciation has been about $10K/yr but the curve should be starting to flatten out.
    Like any used car, buy the newest, best condition and least amount of owners car that meets your budget.
     
  7. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    I was hoping that is the case when it comes to the curve of depreciation. I figured on these models that although they will continue to depreciate that they will not as sharply as the 488. I usually go pretty heavy into new hobbies as long as the experience doesn’t leave me feeling taken advantage of. I guess I’m just trying to avoid that here.


    I’ll definitely be checking out his videos. Although I’m pretty mechanically inclined I would be more concerned about missing a clue that the car had some other type of issue when doing simple oil changes or the like. I know I can do basic maintenance myself but if I look over a maintenance task I don’t know about or miss a leaking seal somewhere I don’t know to look, those are really more of my concern. Getting it into the hands of a dealer/mechanic who can spot those things is my mindset. Unless owners here think that would be over reacting? I just read horror stories of things that can go wrong and the price tag associated with them.
     
  8. versamil

    versamil Formula 3
    Rossa Subscribed

    Apr 28, 2013
    1,158
    Gaston, Oregon
    Full Name:
    Brian Healy
    Bought a used 458 Spider five years ago with 2500 miles. car NOW has 11,500 miles. Cost of maintenance almost NOTHING, with the seven year services provided by Ferrari NA. Problems with the car are a window regulator that ate itself up. Eight hundred dollar part, I installed the replacement myself.

    Horror stories- HUH? Car has been a lot of fun, an event EVERY time I drive it. Depreciation really is the only cost, Original battery. Almost forgot, I did have an LED interior light bulb fail. Go BUY one, and quit overthinking it .At the current prices, the depreciation has mostly occurred. I financed my car through Ferrari Financial, only have two more payments. what a lot of fun it's been.
     
  9. Chadly

    Chadly Formula Junior

    Mar 21, 2010
    294
    Bothell, WA
    Full Name:
    Chad
    458 is very low maintenance. Nothing like the older cars. Though I would make sure you have money aside if a major repair comes up. Sounds like you are financing so I wouldn't stretch yourself on what your payment is going to be. I would also suggest not throwing up on a public forum that you are going to do something illegal to avoid paying taxes lol
     
  10. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    I’d love to believe I’ll be as lucky as you are but my track record would beg to differ. Lol. If I got away with minimal maintenance I’d be happy. Part of the reason I’d like to grab a 15’ hoping it’s within warranty for a good overall inspection prior to falling out of warranty.
    I’d be paying cash, can’t stand paying someone interest on a toy. If you can’t afford a toy outright, save longer and do it the right way. As for the Montana Llc, totally legal as we would have a leasing company to lease out about 4 vehicles.
     
  11. greyboxer

    greyboxer F1 World Champ

    Dec 8, 2004
    12,313
    South East
    Full Name:
    Jimmie
    I may be misreading but your comment re warranty may be erroneous - its a seven year maintenance plan only covering the most basic requirements
     
  12. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Ah, yes you are correct. I kept that maintenance part in mind and morphed it into warranty. Thanks for the correction, shows how green I am with this stuff.
     
  13. versamil

    versamil Formula 3
    Rossa Subscribed

    Apr 28, 2013
    1,158
    Gaston, Oregon
    Full Name:
    Brian Healy
    " If you can’t afford a toy outright, save longer and do it the right way."- everyone has a different reason for buying cars. I was getting LAZY five years ago. and did something to motivate me to continue working. It worked great, I had my highest gross year the first year I bought the car.

    I agree, I would never advertise licensing a car in Montana to save taxes in Illinois .Good luck with that.

    Don't know where people feel that just doing oil changes on a car with less than 20 thousand miles is getting "lucky". The 458's are NOT a Maserati BiTurbo that needed major engine work at 7500 miles. I overhauled at least FIFTY of them in a period of four or five years. What is it, that because it's a Ferrari, it's going to be a money pit. Not so. Why would anybody BUY these cars if they thought they're going to cost thousands to keep on the road? Why SHOULDN'T the car be as reliable as a new Honda of the same year?

    Grabbing a 2015 gets you ONE more oil change under Ferrari service. Don't make that your deciding factor. My last service on my 2013 spider was LAST year. 2019. It's like they counted the initial inspection as the first service.
     
  14. Rexcat458

    Rexcat458 Formula Junior

    Dec 11, 2019
    596
    Full Name:
    Steve
    Hello,

    I’m a first time Ferrari owner and I purchased a 2015 458 Italia Ferrari (dealer CPO) last December. It had a thorough inspection with an excellent report. In the twelve months I’ve owned it, I have had no problems at all (knock on digital wood... ).

    My 458 had three years left on the original seven year maintenance program, (two years left now) so the annual maintenance has been free (to me). It also came with two years of the Power Warranty, of which there is now one year left.

    So no issues, it has been awesome in every respect. Luckily for me, the tires and battery were replaced before I bought the car. I added a Ferrari Collection option that shows “458 Italia” on the ground when you open the door (instead of just a lighted area) that cost $750.00. Original lights were working fine, I just wanted the 458 Italia logo instead.

    Other than petrol and insurance, that’s my only costs so far... The annual insurance was about half what I was paying for a 2018 SonderKlasse 560 4Matic, so I was thrilled! I do not track or worry about depreciation at all. I’m never going to sell it, so it’s not an issue for me. My executor can worry about that, I’m having too much fun driving it!!! YMMV...

    P.S. The previous owner kept her in a heated and air-conditioned car park year round, so no issues with wrinkled leather or sticky buttons thus far. I also keep it in a climate controlled car park at 74 degrees, so I’m hoping she will age ever so gracefully.

    Cheers!
     
  15. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Congrats on the success and this being a motivator. I get that way at times myself, the laziness. The car itself is kind of the motivator for me. Trying to put that money back into the account will eat at me so I’ll push myself to get that money “back” over the next few years.

    I am hopeful the car will be reliable but it’s almost like some owners want to scare others away with their crazy maintenance costs and that sort of perpetuates as rumor. I’ve been conditioned to worry about 10-12k brake jobs. God forbid I had some kind of major failure. I know it’s a car like any other but not being fortunate enough to own one of these yet or experience the costs associated I’m a little concerned and hopefully that’s won’t be founded when I do take the plunge.


    Sounds like you found a gem that didn’t get beat up. Hoping to do the same. I too like the logo you put in, nice touch.
     
  16. Wangotango123

    Wangotango123 Karting

    Aug 7, 2020
    60
    Full Name:
    Rafael olarte
    You sound just lik me a few months ago. Same concerns,same budget and same way of thinking. I was at around 200k but would go further for the right deal. Ended up with a 2018 488. I explored the Montana option but felt the 13k in taxes was tolerable as opposed to the potential issue with any accident and the policy not paying out. If you can afford to stroke a check for 200-250k don’t be that guy. After seeing the 458 market which is on fire I felt more comfortable with regards to taking a huge loss. My rookie observations were that if the car is spec decently with the right color it will sell. I know cause I tried low balling a few dealers they laughed and the car s sold within days causing me to miss out . Ferrari Chat is an awesome tool and enjoy the process. Some people spend 25k on annual dues at a gold club etc . Knowing you are a tiny % of the world with an F car is priceless.
     
  17. VelocityTexas

    VelocityTexas Formula Junior
    Owner Rossa Subscribed

    Oct 21, 2019
    309
    North Texas
    Full Name:
    Bryan
    A spider in that lower price range you mentioned will be tough if you are super anal about every detail being near perfect.
     
  18. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Out of curiosity why did you decide to go with the 488 over the 458? Looked at a 488 today with 2500 miles for 219k. Nice car no doubt just don’t know if that’s a decent deal.
    On dealers asking price, did you find they were firm or had a few percent to negotiate on them?
    As for the Montana thing, I am definitely on the fence. It may be a good move as we purchase a lot of vehicles for our business and if we can operate as a lease company, above board of course, I’d like to vet it out but may find it’s not worth the headache.

    As the new cars start hitting the street and more 458 come free, does it make sense to wait 6-10 months for the spiders to come down a bit or do they seem to be holding? Also what did you consider a decent build on yours? There are a few things I do like for options like the lift and carbon wheel but I just don’t know everything that others find desirable.
    Thank you all for the help and input so far
     
  19. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    What would you think is a better number for a low mile spider?
     
  20. VelocityTexas

    VelocityTexas Formula Junior
    Owner Rossa Subscribed

    Oct 21, 2019
    309
    North Texas
    Full Name:
    Bryan
    That $200k +/- area.
     
  21. Wangotango123

    Wangotango123 Karting

    Aug 7, 2020
    60
    Full Name:
    Rafael olarte
    I’m a boat guy where it’s common to knock down 10% on an asking price. I learned the nice low mileage F cars don’t respond well to the 10% lol.
    The prices of the nice 458s were up there close to 488 territory. Read and read and read saw every video on YouTube and decided the 488 was it. If I would have found a nice 458 if gone that route but for 20-30k more I went with a newer car and sacrificed the sound of the 458. I drove a Tahoe so any fart has better sound anyway.

    As a rookie another thing I learned was price and miles aren’t the complete story. SPEC really plays a big role from my observations. I was able to knock off a whopping $1000 of ask and got shipping included. Ferrari dealer in Miami had identical car and they were in the 240k range sales guy never tried making a deal happen which shocked me. The Ferrari market is very unique. Conventional toy buying didn’t work here for me so paid retail it have a kick ass 488 on the way .
     
    VAF84 likes this.
  22. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Honestly, that approach is exactly what I was expecting. In boating your always negotiating pretty heavily. This seemly is different which is foreign to me. I definitely don’t want to be taken advantage of but I also don’t want to be ignorant and insult anyone which is why I came here for some guidance. Thank you all for the help this far.
     
    VAF84 likes this.
  23. Chadly

    Chadly Formula Junior

    Mar 21, 2010
    294
    Bothell, WA
    Full Name:
    Chad
    The new people that post here are hilarious. That's tax evasion and it's not legal. I would think someone who could afford to pay cash for a Ferrari and a "few" Escalades would be smart enough to know setting setting up a shell LLC in a state you don't operate in, to avoid taxes is against the law. Are you related to the guy who bought the hall of famers house???
     
    IloveGT likes this.
  24. Ndlauer1027

    Ndlauer1027 Rookie

    Dec 26, 2020
    17
    Full Name:
    Neil Lauer
    Thanks for assuming a plethora of things with my inquiry, (insert the old adage here).
    I’d be operating a leasing company who leases at least five vehicles to other companies. Completely above board. That being said I see you are able to contribute something of value to the conversation, I appreciate it.
     
  25. rockminster

    rockminster Formula Junior
    Silver Subscribed

    Nov 20, 2003
    874
    Lake Tahoe
    The OP made a statement suggesting that more 458s will become available as new Ferraris are sold. While there will always be a supply of 458s for sale, we’re past the point of 458 owners trading out of their cars for 488s. It’s likely that we have more 488 owners going back to 458s than vice versa. Also, as people have (re)discovered the 458 value proposition, there are more and more of the best 458s now into planned long term ownership.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    VelocityTexas likes this.

Share This Page