Stephanie, you should ask the gents in the spain thread. Its a huge group & they are very helpful. Spain - FerrariChat.com Have a great time in Ibiza & enjoy your holidays.
It depends what you want to do... If you want to be on the city centre the only alternative you have is the "Gran Hotel". IBIZA GRAN HOTEL - Ibiza Gran Hotel - Contemporary Luxury Experience If you prefer to be a bit away from the centre, in a more rural environment but very very nice you should try "Cas Gasi" inicio - Cas Gasi Ibiza Luxury Boutique Hotel Last week opened a new hotel, owned from Pacha, it is called "Destino", I'm going there mid july, looks very nice and it's 5-10 mins from the centre. Destino Ibiza - Pacha Ibiza Hotel & Resort Enjoy la Isla!